In 1957, the Hogle family donated five acres at the corner of 17th South and Foothill Drive, resolving the question of where a new JCC should be located. The land was to be split evenly between the Episcopal Church and the Jewish community. The Hogle’s gift was readily accepted and the two communities lived in harmony as neighbors.
With a site identified, the Jewish community shifted its focus to building their new home. Dal Siegel led a building committee, which gathered input and worked with architect Robert A. Fowler to produce a plan for the building. Bids were solicited from a number of contractors but all were far in excess of what had been expected and beyond what the community expected to be able to raise. Salt Lake United Jewish Council head Abe Bernstein met with his friend, contractor Joseph Howa, who modified the plans and suggested postponing certain features so that the building could be completed for $350,000, an amount acceptable to the community.